1 Hill St Hill Street CH, St. Croix, 00820 (MLS# 25-2392)

1 Hill St Hill Street CH, St. Croix, 00820

$1,750,000

Villa/ Great House, grounds and cottages

Apartment 4. Two bedroom renovated apartment

Apartment 3. One Bedroom apartment living space

Staircase in Great House leading up to two apartments.

Entrance to Apartment 2 in Villa/Great House.

Apartment 2 patio living space in Villa/Great House

Covered patio on lower level apartment 2, Villa/Great House

Covered patio on lower level apartment apt 2, in Villa/ Great House

Apartment 2 living room in Villa/Great House

Apartment #1 located in the Villa/Great House

Kitchen in efficiency apartment in cottage #1

Bathroom in efficiency apartment cottage #1

Street level apartment located in Villa/Great House.

Living room to street level apartment in Villa/Great House

Dining area to street level aparment in Great House.

Kitchen to Street level apartment in Great House

First bedroom in Street level apartment in Great House

Second bedroom in street level apartment in Great House.

Bathroom in street level apartment in Great House

Property Type: Residential Bedrooms: 9 Baths: 9 Square Footage: 5,029 Lot Size (sq. ft.): 6,098 Status: Active

Current Price: $1,750,000 List Date: 12/20/2025 Last Modified: 3/15/2026

Overview

Description

GOODBYE COLD! Hello ''America's Paradise''! Nestled blocks from St. Croix's main waterfront and boardwalk on prestigious ''Millionaire's Hill,'' this stunning 18th century U.S. Virgin Islands estate in downtown Christiansted offers warm winters and breathtaking panoramic views of the turquoise waters of Christiansted Harbor and the Caribbean Sea. One of St. Croix's most iconic properties, the historic ''Coff House'' features a 4000SF villa with 8 bedrooms and 6 baths, plus 3 additional cottages. Enjoy as 8 income-producing rental units or a multi-family vacation/retirement home, or convert it back to a grand single-family dream home. Beautifully restored and upgraded itself, the surrounding neighborhood is currently undergoing a vibrant renaissance, including...(see supplement tab)

Supplements: ...A new marina and boutique hotel. With shops, entertainment, beaches, and inter-island transportation within easy walking distance, this unique property is at the heart of USVI's hottest neighborhood. Leave your snow shovel behind!

Listing Details MLS# 25-2392

LocationArea

Estate: Hill Street CH
Postal Code: 00820
Directions: Located on the corner of Church and Hill Streets in the town of Christiansted

Contract Information

Begin Date: 2025-12-20
Concessions: No

General Property Description

Realtor.COM Type: Multi-Family
Lot Acres: 0.14
Approx Total Main House: 11100
Approx Total Property SqFt: 5029
Total Bedrooms: 9
Number of Bedrooms - Main House: 7
Number of Bedrooms - Accessory building: 3
Total Bathrooms: 9
Sub Type: 5+ Multi Units
Taxes: 4997.6
Tax Year: 2023
Year Built: 1777
Furnished: Partial
Water Front: No
Pool: No
Zoning: R-3
Stamp Tax: Negotiable
Approx Interior SqFt-Accessory Unit Total: 0
Approx Exterior SqFt-Accessory Unit Total: 0

Miscellaneous

PWD#: 5088

Amenities

Generator: Gas
Other Amenity: Historic Building
Deck: Yes
Gallery: Yes
Gas Grill: Yes
Patio: Yes
Ruins: Yes

More Information

Construction

Other: Danish ballast brick
Mixed: Yes
Wood Frame: Yes

Exterior

Color: Pink
Landscape: Mature
Off Street Parking: Yes
Storm Shutters: Wood

Appliance

Air Conditioning: Split
Dryer: 3
Fans: Yes
Microwave: Yes
Range: Yes
Refrigerator: Yes
Washer: 3

Main House

Additional Units: 5
Approx Interior SqFt - Main House: 5000
Approx Exterior SqFt - Main House: 6100

Unit Info

Individual Meters: Yes

Fees

Internet Amount: 45
Internet Fee Frequency: Monthly
Internet: Yes

Location/Area

Plot/Unit Number: 1 Hill St
Island: St. Croix
Quarter: Christiansted

View

Harbor: Yes
Hillside: Yes
Neighborhood: Yes
Ocean: Yes
Sea: Yes

Flooring

Tile: Yes
Wood: Yes

Upper Baths

Shower/Bath: Yes
Tub: Yes
Shower: Yes

Road

Paved: Yes

Security

24 Hour Monitor: Yes
Gate: Yes

Roof

Fluid Applied: Yes
Pre-Fin Metal: Yes

Fencing

Masonry: Yes
Wood: Yes

Water Source

Cistern: Yes
City: Yes

Sewer

City: Yes

Terrain

Corner Lot: Yes
Hillside: Yes

Property Features

View: Harbor; Hillside; Neighborhood; Ocean; Sea Amenities: Deck; Gallery; Gas Grill; Patio; Ruins Flooring: Tile; Wood Upper Baths: Shower; Shower/Bath; Tub Construction: Mixed; Wood Frame Roof: Fluid Applied; Pre-Fin Metal Fencing: Masonry; Wood Water Source: Cistern Road: Paved Terrain: Corner Lot; Hillside Security: 24 Hour Monitor; Gate Fees: Internet

Documents

Coff House Overview ›

Coff House Blueprints ›

Description of Apartments and Cottages ›

Listing Office: US Virgin Islands Sotheby's International, St. Croix

Office Phone: 340-713-0204

Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.