126G- 4&5 Anna's Retreat NEW, St. Thomas, 00802 (MLS# 25-1583)

126G- 4&5 Anna's Retreat NEW, St. Thomas, 00802

$2,250,000

Inside of where the theater seating used to be.

Located directly across Four Winds Plaza and Wendys

Located on the corner of a busy intersection in a high traffic shopping area

Entrance of the former Pistarkle Theater

Entrance of the Former Pistrakle Theater

Property Type: Commercial Square Footage: 5,333 Lot Size (sq. ft.): 10,454 Status: Active

Current Price: $2,250,000 List Date: 8/18/2025 Last Modified: 1/15/2026

Overview

Description

Discover an exceptional opportunity in the heart of Tillett Gardens with this expansive 5,000 sq. ft. property. Boasting soaring 14' ceilings, a new roof, and plenty of front and rear parking, this space is ready to be transformed to fit your vision. Within the year, the building will feature solid concrete block walls, adding lasting value and durability. Formerly home to the beloved Pistarkle Theater, this property offers incredible versatility—ideal for use as a warehouse, gym, restaurant, flea market, event venue, or creative hub. Its size, location, and flexible layout make it a rare find for entrepreneurs, investors, and business owners looking to bring something dynamic to St. Thomas. With Tillett Gardens' unique character, this space is perfectly positioned for a bold new chapter.

Listing Details MLS# 25-1583

LocationArea

Estate: Anna's Retreat NEW
Postal Code: 00802
Directions: Driving East past Tutu Park Mall turn right at Industrious Auto.

General Property Description

Realtor.COM Type: Commercial
Lot Acres: 0.24
Taxes: 14961.25
Tax Year: 2025
Furnished: No
Water Front: No
Pool: No
Zoning: B-2
Stamp Tax: Select One
Total Bathrooms: 0

Contract Information

Begin Date: 2025-08-09

ListingSelling Member Info

Approx Total Property SqFt: 5333

Miscellaneous

PWD#: D9-4187-T88

Listing Info

Sign: Yes

More Information

Location/Area

Plot/Unit Number: 126G- 4&5
Island: St. Thomas
Quarter: New

Listing/Selling Member Info

Approx Int Sqft: 5333

Amenities

Restaurant: Yes

View

Neighborhood: Yes

Property Features

View: Neighborhood Amenities: Restaurant

Documents

Map of Tillet Gardens ›

Listing Office: Sea Glass Properties

Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.